 "Nice package, great song list, but ..." | 2008-07-11 |
| - Reviewed By User: AZZQ68YERAX0X |
One of my favorite bands from my youth. Cummings had one of the best voices of the era.
But... they really needed to find a way somehow to squeeze Pain Train and Running Back to Saskatoon in here.
Moose Jaw saw a few, Moosomin too
Runnin' back to Saskatoon
Red Deer, Terrace and a Medicine Hat
Sing another prairie tune
Sing another prairie tune |
| |
 "Not 100% Complete In Terms Of Their Greatest Hits - But Close Enough" | 2008-06-22 |
| - Reviewed By avidoldiesfan |
One reviewer bemoans the fact that Bus Rider was not included in this RCA release, but that can be explained by the title of the album which indicates these are their "greatest hits." In other words, those singles of theirs that made it into the Billboard Pop Hot 100 from 1969 to 1974 on RCA Victor. Bus Stop (which I also like very much) was the uncharted B-side to Share The Land, their 9th such hit and a # 10 in late 1970 on RCA Victor 0388.
I say 9th hit because, actually, the group did have their first back in 1965 with the # 22 Shakin' All Over (b/w Till We Kissed) on Scepter 1295, the label founded in 1959 by Florence Greenberg and the long-time home of Dionne Warwick. Up to that point the group had been known as Chad Allan & The Expressions, and when they submitted the demo tape they attached a note saying "Guess Who?" and it was at that point that their band name was changed. They likely penned that note because their rendition was almost an exact copy of the British hit by one major band over there that never became part of the British Invasion - Johnny Kidd & The Pirates.
But, this being an RCA release, it was unfortunately left out of this volume. Their first for RCA was These Eyes, a # 6 in May 1969 b/w Lightfoot on RCA Victor 0102, followed later that summer by the two-sided smash Laughing (# 10) and Undun (# 15 on the Adult Contemporary charts and # 22 Hot 100) on RCA Victor 0195. They then closed out that year with No Time, which peaked at # 5 in January 1970 b/w Proper Stranger on RCA Victor 0300. Then, that spring, they scored their second two-sided hit and only # 1 when American Woman reached the top spot on RCA Victor 0325 b/w No Sugar Tonight (regarded as a "follow-along" hit in the Billboard scheme of things).
To this point, the group (lead vocalist Burton Cummings, Chad "Chad Allen" Kobel, vocals and guitar), Jim Kale on bass, and drummer Gary Peterson), also included guitarist Randy Bachman, who left at this stage to form Bachman-Turner Overdrive. Before Cummings joined in 1966, the group also included pianist Bob Ashley. Bachman had two replacements - guitarists Kurt Winter and Greg Leskiw.
Late in the summer of 1970 this new gathering scored with Hand Me Down World, a # 17 Hot 100 on RCA Victor 0367 b/w Runnin' Down The Street, followed in the late fall by the above-mentioned Share The Land/Bus Rider. In late January 1971, Hang On To Your Life began its climb to # 43, their lowest charter to date on RCA Victor 0414 b/w Do You Miss Me Darlin'? Then, in late spring, they had their third two-sided hit when Albert Flasher got to # 29 on RCA Victor 0458 b/w Broken, a # 55 and, for reasons known only to producer Paul Williams, omitted from this compilation.
Late that summer Rain Dance topped out at # 19 b/w One Divided on RCA Victor 0522, and in December, Sour Suite hit a bit of a sour note as it could only get to # 50 on RCA Victor 0578 b/w Life In The Bloodstream. The struggles continued into 1972 as Heartbroken Bopper could only manage a # 47 on RCA Victor 0659 b/w Arrivederci Girl, Guns, Guns, Guns could get no higher than # 70 in June on RCA Victor 0706 b/w Heaven Only Moved Once Yesterday, and that fall Runnin' Back To Saskatoon, recorded "live" in concert, just barely made the Hot 100 at # 96 on RCA Victor 0803 b/w New Mother Nature (the A-side is also left out of this volume).
Leaving the group in 1972 were Kale and Leskiw, replaced by guitarist Don McDougall and bass player Bill Wallace, but the changes showed only modest improvement in their hits fortunes as Follow Your Daughter Home stalled at # 61 in February b/w Bye Bye Babe on RCA Victor 0880 for their only hit in 1973, the same year that Domenic Troiano, former guitarist with The James Gang, replaced both Winter (who would pass away at age 51 in December 1997) and McDougall.
That paid dividends of sorts in early 1974 as they returned to the Top 40 for the first time in over a year when Star Baby peaked at # 39 b/w Musicione on RCA Victor 0217 and then, a few months later, Clap For The Wolfman - which included a few bits of dialogue by legendary DJ Wolfman Jack - hit # 6on RCA Victor 0324 b/w Road Food. Their final hit single then came late that year when Dancin' Fool finished at # 28 b/w Seems Like I Can't Live With You, But I Can't Live Without You on RCA Victor 10075.
The band disbanded in 1975. Much of this is detailed in the 5 pages of liner notes written by Michael Hill, although there is no proper discography of the contents (which is why I gave that extra information in this review).
With the exception of those two minor hits, this is how a "greatest hits" compilations needs to be done. |
| |
| "BRILLIANT ALL THE WAY" | 2008-05-25 |
| - Reviewed By brsvideoservice |
| This is the best greatest hit's collection so far from the guess who , these songs are pure classics you can't beat'em , A+++++++++++ , highly recommended. |
| |
 "The Guess Who, I guess" | 2008-05-10 |
| - Reviewed By marcelo31 |
| This album enlightened me as to the magnitude of success that the Guess Who enjoyed. I only knew them for 'American Woman' and 'Those Eyes' before I bought this cd. There's a lot more here for anyone that is a fan of 60's music and anyone that listens to Classic Rock will find a lot more hits that they might not have been aware of before. Being only a casual fan of 'The Guess Who' I cannot attest to the completeness of this collection, but I was pleasatly surprised to find that about 70% of the songs are excellent. The remastering is a tremendous improvement to the sound. The only negative comment I would offer is that to someone that is not a huge fan of this era of music, this collection might sound dated, but still, anyone that likes blues-based rock will like the music on this cd very much. |
| |
| "Great first half" | 2008-05-02 |
| - Reviewed By poncho58 |
| The first 8 songs are fantastic, number 9 is OK, then it's way downhill fast. I don't think I'd heard most of these last songs before, and now I know why. |
| |
| "pretty good remake///" | 2008-04-09 |
| - Reviewed By User: A367QVTT5F9XFY |
| i love these great old songs and they sound good...but the intensity varies from song to song. It's nice to hear these again... |
| |
| "Great CD" | 2008-01-19 |
| - Reviewed By User: A2RZGOKDNASQB6 |
| This was also a gift for my daughter. She loves classic rock, just like me! If you liked the Guess Who, this is a must have CD |
| |
| "Stop looking - this is the only G.W. CD you need to buy" | 2008-01-10 |
| - Reviewed By User: A17T6G9TT68U0X |
| A nicely produced CD with all the G.W. songs you would ever want to hear and re-hear. Stop looking - this is the only G.W. CD you need to buy. Then, you're done. Move on. |
| |
| "The Guess Who" | 2007-11-09 |
| - Reviewed By User: AWJMMYL4BPG0J |
| This has all of my favorite songs of the Guess Who! "The Guess Who", the great Canadian rock group that poured psychedelic music around me when I was kid growing up in the 70's this album is groovy and far out man! |
| |
| "WTF! Where is Bus Rider" | 2007-10-24 |
| - Reviewed By cuppa32 |
Don't get me wrong here, I'm glad that these songs are still being released in any form. I heard these tunes when they were first released and the Wolfman was still a DJ. But come on, this piecemeal attitude to music collections has got to stop.
How can you call this collection complete without Bus Rider, which is present on the first collection: Best of the Guess Who? That is one of the best songs on that disc.
In fact, it looks like there are songs scattered across all collections that are not available on one of the other collections. Some the single version, some the album version. There is nothing on the packaging or website that tells you what version of the song you are you are buying. Whether it's a mono or stereo version, full or chopped, Or the worst, a live version or not! Doesn't this violate some truth in advertising laws? Word!
I think these companies should be held to the same standards as other product companies. The exact contents of the recording. If there is more than one version of a song, they have to list what version this is.
The record companies are still up to their old tricks. Make you buy the songs over and over and over again.
I would not mind it so much if they would at least include the absolute complete full song. In fact, include the full song and the single version too. That would be great!
Audio quality is the same as the older collections.
I give this one three stars. I take one away for Bus Rider and one for the chopped version of Clap For The Wolfman.
|
| |
Expedited Available
