Introduction: My brother, Marc, was a great fan of the Beatles. He was almost nine years older than me, and his music was what I listened to (not always by choice!) when I was a kid. My brother died, suddenly and unexpectedly, on 8/6/2002. Today, 8/10/08, would have been his fifty-seventh birthday.
Magical Mystery Tour was the first album I bought, as a cassette tape, that might not have thrilled my parents. They saw The Beatles as hippies and a bad influence, but they did not openly object. I listened to it over and over again, way back when, and still enjoy the songs, for the most part. I now see the album as a mixed bag, quality-wise.
The songs are:
1. Magical Mystery Tour - Where else to start but with the title song? Not every album does, but it makes perfect sense to me. This is a very cheerful, somewhat silly song, and I like it, for the most part, but feel that it has a somewhat weak ending. It is like a tour guide inviting you along for a ride, and the ride is the rest of the album. ****
2. Fool on the Hill - This song seems somewhat of a lyrics-melody mismatch, as the instrumental is cheerful, but the words tell a melancholy tale. It has some real depth to it, as the Fool could be someone under the influence, someone mentally ill, someone who is so rapt up in recreation that he becomes oblivious, or something else entirely. It is interesting to listen to, and is one of my favorites on this album. *****
3. Flying - Hmmm, how did this get here? It is a nice, if not memorable, almost-completely-instrumental piece, with the only vocals not involving any words. It is okay, but no more than that. ***
4. Blue Jay Way - This is easily my least favorite song on this album. Even though I have listened to the album many time, starting decades ago, I keep forgetting it. When I listen to it again, I groan and say, "Why did they do this one?" I find it depressing and shallow, and not worth my time. Maybe I keep forgetting it is that I very much want to forget it. *
5. Your Mother Should Know - This one, as far as mood goes, reminds me a bit of When I'm Sixty-Four, except it is not as catchy or memorable. As far as fitting in with the album, it almost feels like someone said, "We need one more song," and The Beatles complied, similar to when a book feels like the author was writing it to fulfill a contractual obligation to a publisher. ***
6. I Am the Walrus - This is another one from this album that I dislike. It is nonsensical, it meanders, and it is replete with phrases and terms that sound symbolic but, after a while, I get the feeling that The Beatles were just trying to sound inscrutable and enigmatic, to give the impression of depth and profundity, but it has no real depth or meaning to it, as far as I am confirmed. The instrumental part of it is pretty good, though. **
7. Hello Goodbye - Just when you start looking for a towel to throw in, giving up on this album, this gem begins a string of the three best pieces on the album. It is interesting to hear, both musically and lyrically, with a theme of two lovers being completely at odds, without animosity, and drifting away from one another. *****
8. Strawberry Fields Forever - This song is a prime example of me liking something I would not expect to like. If you just read the lyrics, I think the song does not make much sense. But, when I listen to it, I like it. I think it is not a song telling a story, which is what I usually like, but a song meant only to create a feeling or set a mood. It does that, for me, very well. ****
9. Penny Lane - I usually like songs that are about something meaningful and, at first glance, this one is not. It is about ordinary life on a street named Penny Lane. That sounds very mundane and boring. It is not! It sings of neighborhood, home, and community. The melody is cheerful and flowing. Every time I hear this song, I want to stop whatever I am doing and sing along. It is not meaningless. It is about life itself. *****
10. Baby You're a Rich Man - I do like the music and the sound of this song. For some reason, I do not find it memorable. When I listen to it, though, I like it each time, as it talks about how people change when they become wealthy, and how other people might see them. It does get a bit repetitive at the end, though. ****
11. All You Need Is Love - It would have been good to end this album, and this review, on an upbeat note, but it was not meant to be, I guess. This is an odd song, that starts with a brassy fanfare, includes very simplistic lyrics that get repetitive, and I have some concerns about the message. Love is an essential part of life, in my opinion, but if you understand the terms of formal logic, there is a big difference between necessary and sufficient. Air and food are necessary parts of human life, but we die without water, a strong and stable immune system, shelter, and many other things. In other words, air is necessary to life, but it is not sufficient. This song repeatedly forwards the idea that "love is all you need," which means it is a necessary and sufficient ingredient. Maybe I am being way too picky, and I can be, at times, but if you put a point on the table, over and over again, it better stand up to scrutiny. This song does not do so, and it just annoys me. The instrumentals are good, and the voices do sound good, but thumbs down on the message. **
Overall: Many albums have an underlying, connective message, or theme, like chapters in a book. That is not necessary, but I like it, when it is there. This album is at the opposite end of the spectrum. It is a hodgepodge compilation of songs that vary markedly in quality, mood, depth, and message. I still have very fond memories of it from childhood, but that does not make it a good album. It is redeemed, somewhat, by the second, seventh, and ninth songs, and Penny Lane is one of the best work by the group. As an album, it earns thirty-eight of a possible fifty-five stars, or an average rating of 3.45 stars. |
International Available
![The Beatles - Rubber Soul [UK]](product_images/183000/183442_thumb.jpg)
![The Beatles - Revolver [UK]](product_images/183000/183386_thumb.jpg)
"One of My Fav.s"
"In memory of my brother"
"Not as good as Sgt Pepper"
"For Beatles fans and old hippies"