 "Interesting historical perspective, but writing style can be over-the-top" | 2008-08-30 |
| - Reviewed By User: A25A4JC5ZCZK7K |
It is difficult for me to say whether or not I liked this book. While I am drawn to its narrative, which covers several generations of Asian Americans, I had a hard time stomaching the author's style at certain points. For example:
"'This is a terrible idea!' Eddy yelled, whacking his hand through the air like a karate master trying to split a pile of bricks."
"Why did one child, one husband, and no job create such a crushing burden for Stella? Because she had already been crushed by her childhood... [B]ecause her hopes, her expectations, her dreams had been crushed."
Overall, I'd recommend this for anyone interested in Asian American history, but I personally would not purchase it for my library. |
| |
 "What a great family history written as a novel" | 2008-07-12 |
| - Reviewed By msze88 |
| I enjoyed this book very much. Amazing to read about one man's dreams and hard work from 4 generations ago still leaves a legacy and a still-running store to this day. I was broken-hearted reading about the treatment of the Chinese during the railroad building era of the West. Bigotry and racism are not new to America, and not limited to just Africans. I got confused sometimes with all the names, and had to refer to the family tree in the beginning of the book, but it was a wonderful story. |
| |
 "A Scrutable Family Success" | 2008-07-02 |
| - Reviewed By sidereusnuntius |
There's not much magic realism or mystic exoticism about this blunt, detailed, multi-generational history of an immigrant family. If you're looking for a novel, you'll find that Lisa See has written several. I repeat, this is a history, and it will be of interest chiefly to historians and other social scientists, professional or arm-chair.
Ms. See's great-great-grandfather arrived in America in 1867. The shabby treatment that he and other Chinese immigrants received is part of American history, but here in this book it becomes more vivid because See includes the reader in her "family album." Suffice it to say that the Fong/See family shrugged off indignities, worked hard, brought kinfolk to share the work despite arbitrary and unfair hurdles, took root in America, and succeeded more or less to the measure of their immigrant dreams. So it was with my mother's immigrant family from North Europe, and so it has been with every immigrant complement to America's cultural universality. Quite a few of the Fong/See second-comers spent time at the detention center of Angel Island, as described in the book "Island" which I reviewed a few days ago.
The drama in this history of the branching See family - what makes this book memorable - is a love story, the secret and perilous marriage of Fong See, the son of the 1867 immigrant, to a woman of European heritage, Letticie Pruett. Interracial marriage was illegal for decades in California, as in many states, and the penalties were a lot more severe than mere annulment. The Fong See clan ran the risk of deportation, and the couple had reason to fear ostracism and personal violence.
There's a sheaf of family photos in the center of the book. There's a snapshot of Richard See - fourth generation, I believe - with his buddies in Levis and Pendletons, getting ready for a fishing trip. Then there's Lisa herself as a girl in Chinese silks, but gasp! Lisa has wide European eyes, long blonde hair, and freckles!
My mother's sister and her Norwegian-American husband Jim, the last of my Minnesota kin to live on a homestead farm, came to visit me in San Francisco in the 1970s. One evening I took them, with other relatives and friends, to a Chinese restaurant. Jim is not what you'd call loquacious; he was sitting with his back to the room and paying more heed to the talk at other tables than to us. Just behind him, a family was talking about visits to colleges, arguing the merits of Cal Tech versus MIT. Jim got curious and turned around - discretely? oh yeah! - to see what the family looked like. Then he gaped at me and whispered "them folks are Chinese!" "Well," said I, "what do you expect in a Chinese restaurant?" "But they're speakin' English!" quoth he.
The heart and soul of Lisa See's history of her extended family is exactly what my uncle didn't understand. The Chinese who came to America were not insidious strangers and inscrutable menaces to European American culture. They were just plain folk.
|
| |
| "Enjoyable read, a history lesson" | 2008-06-02 |
| - Reviewed By User: A21NT0LVL7QE9F |
| I had read "Snow Flower and the Secret Fan" and just loved it. This book is just as absorbing. The reader is transported to another time and place. I enjoy historical fiction. This is a good story based on the history of Lisa See's family. It was obviously a labor of love for her. I would recommend it especially to those who are interested in West Coast history, from the late 19th century to WWII-era. |
| |
| "Truly relocating you to a different time, a different place" | 2008-04-02 |
| - Reviewed By mzrizz |
I cannot express what wonderful storytelling of 100 years odyssey this book was. It was filled with historic detail, from China to the United States, as they referred to it as Gold Mountain. The patriach, Fong See was a merchant, and you will learn plenty of the business side of the family. He rented furniture to Hollywood studios. The many descriptive characters stories are well-tracked, and clearly identified. There is no confusion.
Lisa is with interracial heritage, which makes the telling of the past more interesting as we learn that aspect of her family's life. Although a long read, it was insightful, informative, intriguing with mystery, concubines, romance, business, immigration, travel, etc. This book is an enthralling read with every chapter advancing to more.
|
| |
| "The diversity of living" | 2008-03-29 |
| - Reviewed By User: A3HJGMA4MOO63T |
I read On Gold Mountain slowly, with days between chapters to think about new ideas. On Gold Mountain was many things to me. A true story, it captures the diversity of life: hopeful and heartbreaking; success and failure; riches and poverty; love, courage and pride. In the many lives of the See family and other Chinese immigrants, opportunity, danger, effort and chance all play a role in deciding who will be rich, who will live and who will die.
It was an eye-opening revelation to me of how racist our laws and immigration policies were towards the Chinese, up until our recently.
It was an amazing journey into Chinese society both in America and in China.
It was an uplifting and hopeful account of how, in spite of everything, Chinese immigrants were able to come to America, work, and prosper.
It was a heart-breaking indictment of the treatment of the Chinese by our government and big business, particularly the railroads. The suffering and death of so many people has gone too long unnoticed in our history books.
It was an amusing commentary on the foibles of human nature, and how love truly can triumph over it all, down through the generations.
It was an incredibly well-researched, well-documented and remarkably frank story of one Chinese immigrant and his numerous descendants.
In the developing field of social history, and using social history to illuminate a genealogy, On Gold Mountain is a seminal work, published five years prior to the ground-breaking "Bringing Your Family History to Life through social history" by Katherine Scott Sturdevant. As such, it is a remarkable example of the professional standards to which the social historian/genealogist may aspire.
Although the family history is rife with bi-racial marriage, multiple wives and concubines, infidelity and divorce, Lisa See presents the story in a sympathetic and factual manner, and avoids sensationalizing her family history. It is as much about the family business of importing Asian art, furniture and folk items, and other businesses the younger generations developed, as it is about the personal history of the family.
I would recommend Lisa See's book to anyone planning to write a social history; to all high school and college students in classes on U. S. Government, sociology, immigration, and capitalism. I would also recommend it to anyone who likes a good work of non-fiction about real people. |
| |
| "A perfect example of how a family history should be written" | 2007-12-27 |
| - Reviewed By User: A2E3GFHUDNPYDH |
Genealogy buffs would do well to read this "One-Hundred-Year Odyssey of [Lisa See's] Chinese-American History" as an excellent example of how to write their own family histories. See, one-eighth Chinese, interviewed "close to one hundred people" and with help, found historical information from the late 1880s about her great-great grandfather's generation on up to her own children by perusing documents such as immigration records, photographs, letters, diaries, etc., that is, in the usual way. The result, On Gold Mountain "the Chinese name for the United States," almost 400 pages in length, is an in-depth, well-written account of the happenings in the lives of her ancestors, cousins, aunts and uncles. But anyone who knows anything about genealogy will agree that while a person's own genealogical information is, or can be, quite thrilling, another's is usually significantly less so. The main "character" of the family history, Fong See, was a polygamist. His second marriage, to a white woman (his first, unconsummated, was to a young girl in China) created the line from which the author descended. He was a merchant by trade who sold undergarments to prostitutes (during which he met his Lisa See's great-grandmother). Later, he dealt in antiques and other merchandise, creating a name for himself both in the Chinatown area of Los Angeles and in Dimtao, his home village in China, to which he provided monetary assistance. While the information on the lives of Chinese immigrants in general (including the ever-changing, often discriminatory immigration policies) and Fong See in particular, were great reading, the book was exceedingly long and overly detailed. I, for one, am not really interested in the names and occupations of Ms. See's first cousins. And less annoying but worth mentioning is the fact that the book's standard format, consistent and chronological, changes dramatically at Chapter 11. Memories: Tyrus Tells His Story reads like a taped interview might sound. In Chapter 14, Anna May Speaks (from the Grave), a film star, unrelated to the Sees except as a family friend, complains about her mistreatment by the film industry, the Americans, and the Chinese. Chapter 15, which I like to call The Improperly Edited Chapter, contains nine paragraphs beginning with a single word or short phrase (Pp 247-250), "Wives," "Children," "Grandchildren," "Business," "More business," "Business and family," "The Japanese crisis," "Partners," and "Life story." Lastly, the inclusion of a reference to California's Prop 187 (p 355) "Through Proposition 187, illegal immigrants would be barred from receiving any state funds; this meant no education, no welfare, and no medical care, except in dire emergencies," seems a bit unfair. China's policies concerning illegal immigrants are certainly much stricter than the USA's. In summary, Lisa See is a very good storyteller, has produced a great example of a family history and a tribute to her ancestors, but the audience of interest for the overly long overly detailed On Gold Mountain is likely limited to Fong Dun Shung's descendants, fans of the historical aspects of Chinese immigration to America (or their life in America) during the late 1880s and early 1900s, and genealogy buffs. And if I weren't part of the last category, I'd have either quit the book or slogged through and given it only two stars. Better: The Kitchen God's Wife by Amy Tan, the Bonesetter's Daughter by Amy Tan, and Snow Flower and the Secret Fan by Lisa See.
|
| |
| "Made a nice gift" | 2007-09-21 |
| - Reviewed By simplyodd |
| The person I gave this to thought it was a very nice read and recommends it. |
| |
| "Incredible Book" | 2007-07-31 |
| - Reviewed By ekkiegirl |
| I am a new fan of Lisa See and I have to say that this is one of the best books I have ever read. It is a fascinating story. There were times I had to remind myself that this was a work of non-fiction. I only wish there were more photographs. A great read and hard to put down. |
| |
| "generational story" | 2006-11-10 |
| - Reviewed By thood13 |
| I like Lisa See's books and this is another example of her fine writing. This time, however, her focus is the story of her own family and their impact on their new country. |
| |
Expedited Available
