 "Interesting but not really helpful" | 2007-06-04 |
| - Reviewed By Omer Belsky from Haifa, Israel |
Is it Hubris to review a book on a country you know absolutely nothing about? More like Chutzpa, I guess, that perennial curse of us Jews. Although I know little about Nigeria, I hope I can offer fellow clueless Amazonians a taste of what this book is like, and maybe even give people who know something about Nigeria a fresh perspective (well, I said maybe).
I occasionally read books about unfamiliar countries to slightly dispell my general ignorance, but I have to say the "The Trouble with Nigeria" did not do much to enrich my knowledge of this poor little African Country (not so little, actually - it is apparently bigger then France). I learned this little fact about Nigeria's size from Wikipedia. Achebe spares us such mandane details as the size, population, and per capita GDP of Nigeria. He's more interested in maladies such as corruption, immaturity, and tribalism. As a consequence, the vast majority of the book is useless as a source of information to outsiders. Only the last couple of chapters actually bring some useful information, and even then, it is clearly targeted to those in the know.
There are two things to praise about Achebe's book. Achebe avoids both extremes in search of answers to the questions of Nigeria's ills; too often in human history, people have attempted to blame the failure of non-Western societies on their genetic makeup. Achebe rightly rejects this answer forthwith: "There is nothing basically wrong with Nigerian character" (p.1). Another response, more understandable and reasonable, and yet equally unproductive, is to blame the West, Imperialism, and Colonialism. Knowing very little Nigerian History, no doubt a good case can be made that British Colonial rule has been a disaster. But Achebe does not seek to cast blame - he seeks avenues for reform, and for that he should be commanded.
But for Achebe the problems of Nigeria are two-fold: Corruption and Tribalism. That is an oversimplified analysis and won't do. Take corruption first; Achebe quotes shockingly forthright statements by major Nigerian politicians who claim their planning of promoting their own self interest. (pp. 59-60). That is very unromantic, but not terribly surprising. Powerful people are usually ambitious people; even the best politicians, such as the American Founding Fathers, have had their share of pettiness and greed. As we agree that Nigerians are no better nor worse then other people, why would they be singularly blessed with lousy leaders?
Or take tribalism; Achebe observes that tribalism is a serious problem in Nigeria, as tribal identity is often as strong or stronger then national identity. He fails to mention that Nigeria has 250 different ethnic groups speaking some five hundred languages! (Wikipedia again) Another admission of ignorance of all things Nigerian is due here, but I am generally skeptical about the viability of multi-ethnic states. The possibility that a divided Nigeria would be an improvement should be considered, as should the proper form of government to direct such a complex country.
Achebe makes only the scantest mention of comparable African states (p.20). African countries are severely disadvantaged because of their geographical position, historical development, and legacy of Western colonialism. Setting reasonable goals in comparison with other African states, and learning from the successes and failures of other African states is essential for improving the state of Nigeria.
Finally, I'd like to raise a point not mentioned by Mr. Achebe's book: Oil. Nigeria is, to its misfortune, an oil rich country. Oil is a great burden to underdeveloped countries, because it fosters the growth of a small and extremely powerful social stratum that can monopolize its profits. Like mines in Latin America, oil causes great wealth inequalities and hinders democracy. I would be very surprised if Oil wasn't one cause for Nigeria's trouble, and learning to cope with it would have to be a priority.
Chinua Achebe's book is impassioned and well written, but unfortunately it is analytically defective. It contains scarcely any insights from economics, social science, or historical perspective; Of course, it is not that kind of book, but that is the point - it is only that kind of book that can help a country such as Nigeria. So I am afraid I cannot recommend "The Trouble with Nigeria". |
| |
 "Another well written book by Achebe." | 2006-02-13 |
| - Reviewed By Emily Livermore |
This book, for me, was an eye opener to the problems in Nigeria. Chinua Achebe talks about how the main problem in Nigeria is the leadership. He did a really good job of proving that the real problem was the failure in leadership. He talked about indiscipline, tribalism, social injustice, and corruption. Even though he talked about the problems of the leadership, he still mentioned and commended Aminu Kano for not being selfish, like most of the leaders, and putting the nation's interests before his own. This book gave me a view, from a Nigerian's perspective, about the real problems in Nigeria.
I think people should definitely consider reading this book. It is a quick read (only 63 pages) and it is very influential. Along with being short, it is for the most part easy to follow and it gives a lot of details, facts, and his opinions of what is going wrong in Nigeria. The only thing I didn't like about this book was some parts in the last chapter when Achebe almost went too much in detail. In the beginning it was really interesting to me, but in the last chapter, the information and facts were harder to soak in. Even though I didn't like parts of the last chapter, I still recommend this book and I think that it is worth it to read it.
Compared to Things Fall Apart, this book is a lot shorter and is a little bit denser. They are both quick reads, and I think if Nigeria interests you, then it is worth it to read both of them. All of the books that I have read by Achebe so far have impressed me, and I think that he is not only an influential writer, but his writing is also fun to read.
|
| |
 "PASSIONATE ANALYSIS OF THE TROUBLE WITH NIGERIA" | 2004-08-13 |
| - Reviewed By Amazonia from Manaus, Amazonas, Brazil |
Achebe, the great writer from Nigeria (author of THings Fall Apart and others), provides a passionate and smart analysis of the real problems preventing development in Nigeria.
This book is a bit political and local, meaning that if you don't know the characters you will not get about 10% of the book. He cites examples and tells stories that are clearly very familiar to locals, but not to outsiders. Such writing makes me believe that the audience aimed is in fact Nigerians rather than outsiders.
However, there are important lessons from outsiders, which are condensed into the less than 100 pages of this small book. Issues such as corruption and disrespect for laws are addressed from a very different standpoint than usual economists would. The ideas and concepts from this book are applicable to other countries facing difficulties reaching high standards of living. I, for one, wish someone had written such a book on Brazil. It is a quick read, worth your 2 hours. |
| |
| "an important diatribe" | 2000-10-25 |
| - Reviewed By An Amazon User |
| This is a good little book about Nigeria's problems written by a Nigerian for Nigerians. The edition I read was one of the smallest books I've ever seen - even smaller than some of those Noam Chomsky Real Story tracts - which makes sense since it was published in Nigeria for readers who might not be able to afford paying $8.50 for a book. Therefore the reader should keep in mind the audience this book is aimed at: Achebe is writing to Nigerians about how they can clean up their country. He is not writing a serious book about the current troubles of Nigeria and how they can be solved on an international as well as domestic front: the lack of the words 'Shell Corporation' is conspicuous throughout the book. That being said, this is a good way for a non-Nigerian to see how Nigeria's problems are perceived internally. Achebe is strong in his condemnation of tribalism, indiscipline and especially corruption and the prejudice agains the Igbo people. While condeming most current (this was written in 1983) politicians, he does praise the famous Aminu Kano and other politicians like Bola Ige, Bisi Onabanjo and Ernest Ikoli for putting the nation's interest first, not their own. Achebe looks forward to a time when such politicians would lead Nigerians, not divide them or waste their money needlessly. Unfortunately, good leadership is not the only answer to Nigeria's problems. Nonetheless, this is still a worthy read. |
| |
| "This should be required reading..." | 2000-08-05 |
| - Reviewed By Michael E. Evans from Charleston, SC United States |
| I first bought this book from a dusty bin in The Metropolitan Hotel in Calabar, Nigeria. I was there on a thirteen day missions trip during the bloody reign of Babangida and I had already experienced, first hand, the trouble with Nigeria. Achebe had been a favorite author since I read Things Fall Apart during my college days, but with this reading he became more than an author -- he became a friend and guide. In 63 insightful pages he has written a manifesto for the recovery of people of African descent world-wide, of which I am one. He talks about the need for leadership, the scar of tribalism, and a variety of social ills that, as he puts it, Nigerians have relegated to small talk and I am sad to say African Americans have turned into comedy. This is a must read for people of African descent and anyone else who would like to understand and help. Just recently, I had the privilege of meeting and interviewing the daughter of former Nigerian President Elect Abiola. Her father died while imprisoned a few years ago. Now a congresswoman herself, she has high hopes for Nigeria, but sees similar social ills here in American and agreed that Achebe's views are accurate and needful. The trouble with Nigeria and African America is that not enough people have read and applied the principles discussed in The Trouble with Nigeria. |
| |
Expedited Available
